This bill modifies the legal framework for construction defect claims, particularly for middle market housing, by adding procedural requirements, extending the statute of limitations, and increasing homeowner association approval thresholds for lawsuits.
Key Provisions of the Bill1. Stricter Filing Requirements for Construction Defect Lawsuits (Section 3)
Anyone filing a construction defect lawsuit against an architect or engineer must also submit:
An affidavit from a third-party licensed professional (e.g., another architect or engineer) that details the negligence, error, or omission.
New Presumption Against Defects:
If a state agency or local government issued a certificate of occupancy, the property is presumed to be free of defects.
This presumption is rebuttable, meaning claimants can still argue otherwise, but they must provide stronger evidence.
2. Claimant Responsibilities & Required Construction Professional Responses (Section 4)
Duty to Mitigate:
A claimant must take reasonable steps to mitigate the defect.
The bill outlines how to meet this duty and the consequences of failing to do so.
Required Response from Construction Professionals:
If a claimant notifies a construction professional of a defect, the professional must either:
Offer to settle the claim, or
Submit a written response explaining the applicable construction standards and why the alleged defect does not require repair.
Additional Information Disclosure:
A construction professional defending against a defect lawsuit must provide specific information to the claimant about the construction.
3. Changes to Statute of Limitations for Construction Defect Claims (Sections 5 & 6)
Default statute of limitations: 10 years.
Reduced statute of limitations: 6 years if the construction professional provided a consumer warranty that meets the bill’s requirements.
Statute of limitations/repose is paused (tolled) while a claimant is actively mitigating a defect.
4. Affirmative Defenses for Construction Professionals (Section 7)
Construction professionals who meet certain requirements may use affirmative defenses against construction defect claims.
These legal protections could help reduce liability risks for builders of middle market housing.
5. Stricter Requirements for HOA-Filed Construction Defect Lawsuits (Section 8)
Increased HOA Approval Threshold:
Currently, a majority (51%) of unit owners must approve a construction defect lawsuit.
The bill increases this threshold to 65%.
Use of Damages from Lawsuits:
If an HOA wins monetary damages in a lawsuit, the first priority must be to repair the defects before any other use of funds.
Summary
Stricter filing requirements for lawsuits, including a third-party affidavit for claims against architects/engineers.
New legal presumption that properties with a certificate of occupancy do not have defects (unless proven otherwise).
Homeowners must mitigate defects before suing.
Construction professionals must respond to defect claims with either a settlement offer or explanation.
Statute of limitations extended to 10 years, but only 6 years if a proper warranty is provided.
HOAs must get 65% owner approval (instead of 51%) before filing lawsuits.
Damages from lawsuits must first be used for repairs.
Summary
For construction of middle market housing, section 3 of the bill
requires a person filing a construction defect action against an architect or engineer to file with the complaint an affidavit of a third-party licensed professional indicating the negligence or other action, error, or omission of the construction professional. Section 3 also establishes a rebuttable presumption that a property does not have a construction defect when a state agency or local government has issued a certificate of occupancy for the property. Section 4:
Establishes a claimant's duty to mitigate an alleged construction defect and specifies how a claimant may satisfy this duty and the consequences to a claimant that fails to satisfy this duty;
Requires that a construction professional must send or deliver to the claimant an offer to settle the claim or a written response that identifies the standards that apply to the claim and explains why the defect does not require repair; and
Requires a construction professional who is the defendant in a construction defects action to submit specified information to the claimant. Section 5 updates the statute of limitations for construction defect
claims to 10 years unless the construction professional provided the consumer with a warranty that meets the requirements of the bill, in which case the statute of limitations is 6 years. Section 6 tolls the statute of limitations or repose during a claimant's mitigation of an alleged construction defect claim brought for the construction of middle market housing. Section 7 allows a construction professional that meets specified
requirements to use certain affirmative defenses in construction claims brought against the construction professional for the construction of middle market housing.
Current law requires the executive board of a unit owners'
association (executive board) to obtain approval from a majority of owners before initiating a construction defect claim on behalf of the owners. Section 8 increases the approval amount to 65%. Section 8 also requires an executive board that is successful in a construction defect claim to first use monetary damages received as a result of the claim to repair the construction defect.